Harm Reduction for Methamphetamine Users
Part Two of Two
Current literature provides ample information linking methamphetamine use with HIV transmission, particularly among men who have sex with men and injection drug users. Studies have documented alarming rates of unprotected sex, increased numbers of sexual partners, and high prevalence of HIV and other sexually transmitted diseases among methamphetamine users.1-4 Harm reduction counseling can fill a critical gap in addressing the health needs of users who may not be reached by other responses such as drug treatment or substance use prevention.
Characteristics of Methamphetamine
The pharmacology, behavioral norms, and neurological impact of methamphetamine use present unique challenges to harm reduction approaches. A typical methamphetamine high lasts 8 to 12 hours (a cocaine high lasts only 15 to 30 minutes) and often stretches into a longer "run" during which a user maintains a high, usually without sleep, for days or even weeks. Several days of exhaustion, sleep, and acute depression, known as the "crash," follow the high. During these extended ups and downs, methamphetamine users may be too distracted, exhausted, or secluded to engage in clinical interventions.
Additionally, the paranoia or psychosis that can result from chronic use or sleep deprivation often keeps users away from services such as needle exchange, drug treatment, and health clinics, all traditional engagement points for users of other drugs. Cognitive impairment as a result of chronic drug use, concurrent mood or hyperactivity disorders, and compulsive sexual behavior are typical and add to the complexity of counseling methamphetamine users. While the philosophy and objective of harm reduction -- the support of positive, incremental change towards client-defined goals -- do not differ depending on the drug of choice, the implementation of harm reduction does. Applying the harm reduction mantra "meeting users where they are at" can be difficult with methamphetamine users, whose exact "at" points are either hidden beneath layers of distrust or are constantly shifting in waves of drug-induced impulsivity. This article discusses how service delivery and counseling might be structured to further harm reduction goals for people who use methamphetamine.
Methamphetamine use impairs attention span, memory acuity, impulse control, learning function, and abstract thinking. This diminishes users' abilities to process or recall information and to conduct abstract cognitive functions such as perceiving risk and consequences, making decisions, and prioritizing actions. To accommodate these deficits and enhance client engagement and retention, implementing service elements such as telephone reminders, flexible "no-show" policies, and access to multiple services in one visit or location can be useful.
Mornings, Mondays, and Fridays (when users are often high or crashing) tend to be poor times for service utilization. Evenings and mid-week days work better. Drop-in hours rather than strict appointment schedules, very brief (or no) intake forms, and shortened waiting times better serve these clients, who tend to react spontaneously to their own needs and have diminished tolerance for stress and frustration.
Addressing Harms of Methamphetamine
Given the nature of methamphetamine use, there are three key harms that might be minimized through counseling. To compensate for client impulsivity and impaired judgment, counselors should help clients develop personalized plans to avoid harm and maintain safety before getting high.
The most basic harm reduction message for users addresses essential human needs: eat, drink water, and sleep. Meeting these needs will help the body withstand highs, ease crashes, and delay the onset of paranoia -- all effective "selling points" for users.
Sexual activity is a second focal point. Methamphetamine can be a powerful sexual stimulant for both men and women, resulting in longer-lasting, more frequent, and more compulsive sex than that observed among other drug users. Sexual activity may also diverge from core sexual identity, for example, allowing straight-identified men to have sex with other men. Not all users, however, are conflicted by this behavior-identity discordance, claiming rather that "On meth, I'm just sexual." Counselors should avoid interpreting this behavior as orientation confusion; instead, they should assist clients reducing undesirable consequences such as HIV and sexually transmitted disease transmission, pregnancy, or involvement with abusive partners. Again, counselors should encourage clients to think through sexual decisions and make sexual safety plans before getting high.
Lastly, commonly shared beliefs among users can contribute to risk taking and harm. Many methamphetamine users consider their drug to be more "functional" than heroin or cocaine. Methamphetamine users see themselves as "getting things done," including purposeful activities such as sex, work, or home maintenance. They see heroin or cocaine users as spending their highs nodding off or looking for more drugs. This belief in methamphetamine's "benefit" can nurture feelings of invulnerability to negative consequences. In addition, methamphetamine users see the drug as representing excitement, personal power, escape from restrictive norms, and a desirable risk.
These beliefs may interfere with perception and appreciation of harm. At the same time, however, they offer harm reduction providers effective "leverage points." Counselors may encourage clients to make positive behavior changes in order to sustain their "high" activities. For example, a male client may cut down on escalating drug use if he is concerned that drug-induced impotence will interfere with desirable sexual activity. Sensation seeking clients may be more open to discussing "harmful" behaviors if counseling affirms this aspect of their personality and allows them to define "risk" or negative consequences for themselves.
Dealing With Paranoia
Perhaps the greatest challenge when providing services to methamphetamine users is overcoming distrust and paranoia. Providers may experience difficulty in developing rapport with clients. Understanding methamphetamine vocabulary or use practices and showing patience with impulsive, unfocused, and suspicious behaviors can help demonstrate provider knowledge and acceptance.
Trying to convince clients what is real and what is not is rarely successful and almost always frustrating. Instead, counselors should help clients recognize their own patterns of paranoia and identify ways to reduce anxiety and possible harmful outcomes of paranoid behavior such as arrest, violence or self-injury. An effective counseling probe may be, "I don't see the people following you, so tell me when they appear and leave. How does it change when you are high or crashing? What helps you feel safer?" This approach validates clients' emotional experiences without necessarily "buying into" their delusions.
Counselors can also structure counseling settings to minimize paranoia, for example, by facing clients away from doors or windows, closing window curtains, dimming bright lights, and avoiding sitting behind desks. Some clients may be suspicious of note taking or other clinical documentation. Ask clients at the outset if they feel comfortable and make appropriate accommodations.
As the epidemic of methamphetamine use continues, counselors are likely to encounter more clients who are using. Despite the challenges of working with these clients, there is opportunity for behavior change success, particularly when harm reduction approaches are tailored to meet the unique needs of clients.
Author Susan Kingston is an Educator Consultant with the Drug Use and HIV Prevention Team at Public Health-Seattle and King County. She specializes in prevention strategies for substance-using men who have sex with men.
Gorman, EM, Clark, CW, Welch, SP, et al. Women, risk and speed: Implications for HIV, hepititis C prevention among female methamphetamine users. Presentation at the 1999 National HIV Prevention Conference. Atlanta, August, 1999.
Halkitis, PN, Parsons, JT. Recreational drug use and HIV-risk sexual behavior among men frequenting urban gay venues. Journal of Gay and Lesbian Social Services. 2002; 14(4): 19-38.
Molitor F, Truax SR, Ruiz JD, et al. Association of methamphetamine use during sex with risky sexual behaviors and HIV infection among non-injection drug users. Western Journal of Medicine. 1998; 168(2): 93-97.