HIV Spotlight on Center on Caring for the Newly Diagnosed Patient


Unraveling the Impact of Trauma on People With HIV -- and Their Care Providers

An Interview With Edward Machtinger, M.D.

July 21, 2014

 < Prev  |  1  |  2  |  3 

From Modeling to Implementation: Helping Patient Behaviors and Choices Seem Less Mysterious

"For us, the epiphany -- and what's so exciting -- has been that understanding the impact of trauma feels like a way to be far more effective in the work that we are doing."

That sounds like a lot. Primary care clinics are already overwhelmed in many regards by the requirements placed upon them. And to some, adding screening for lifelong and recent abuse sounds like yet another task. But for us, the epiphany -- and what's so exciting -- has been that understanding the impact of trauma feels like a way to be far more effective in the work that we are doing.

To us, it helps explain why so many of our patients are still smoking crack cocaine, despite having an array of services available to them here in clinic, including therapy, social work, case management, substance abuse counseling and supportive primary care physicians. It helps explain why our waiting room is just so chaotic, and people act at times so dysfunctionally. It helps explain why some people just can't take their antiretroviral medications, despite intensive pharmacy support. Understanding the role of trauma makes these situations feel less mysterious to us. And it helps me, as a clinician, feel far more compassionate about my patients who are struggling to be healthy in their lives.

For example, when I am engaging somebody who is actively smoking crack cocaine, I now tend to say, "Of course you're smoking crack cocaine. Crack is obviously providing you with something helpful in your life. Let's talk about the good things about crack cocaine, and how it's helping you." Underlying that is my understanding that many people who are smoking crack cocaine have PTSD from having had a lifelong history of childhood sexual and physical abuse, adult sexual and physical abuse, and intimate partner violence that has led them to be profoundly anxious and isolated. And crack cocaine has been one of the few ways of coping with that. Unless we can address their underlying profound anxiety, dealing with their substance abuse and medication non-adherence and health issues is just not going to be effective.

For clinics interested in making this transition, what's the first step?

Is there a potential danger in opening a Pandora's box by not fully implementing a trauma-informed primary care approach?


The model of trauma-informed primary care that we articulate is aspirational. Very few primary care clinics or clinicians have the power to change their clinical environment to become trauma informed, initiate comprehensive screening and begin performing interventions that are evidence-based into recent and past trauma. Most of us don't have the buy-in from our institutions, the resources or power to do all of that.

I do not think it is necessary to implement a comprehensive model of trauma-informed primary care to begin utilizing the understanding of trauma and its impact on patients to help our patients heal. I think the first step would be to educate ourselves about the role trauma plays in the lives of our patients, and how our clinics themselves -– the care environments -- are either helping our patients heal or triggering their trauma even further.

I think we have come to accept that frontline poverty AIDS clinics are by nature chaotic. And many of us have actually been drawn to this field because of that chaos.

What I've come to realize is that that chaos is not serving our patients, and it's not serving us, as providers, and that our clinical environment needs to acknowledge that the way we treat our patients and the way we treat each other and support one another have a big impact on how our patients respond to our medical care.

"Understanding their histories of trauma has led me to have far more effective, real conversations with patients about those issues."

The other thing I would suggest is being willing to start asking the questions. So many of us in HIV are surprised that people outside of the field of HIV are terrified to even raise the topic of HIV. People outside of the field of HIV don't want to know about someone being HIV positive, because they fear that they won't know how to handle it. And we in the field of HIV are always surprised about that, because HIV is a health condition, like any other health condition.

Similarly, even in our field, people are scared to ask about abuse. Yet most of us know how to deal with a positive response to questions about recent or past trauma -- that a danger assessment, safety planning or referrals to community organizations are the first step to help a woman who's experiencing acute intimate partner violence become more safe. Simply knowing about past abuse may help us care for our patients over time, so that their current behaviors (which may include substance addiction, or depression, or medication non-adherence) or other factors in their lives can be understood in that context. In my experience, understanding their histories of trauma has led me to have far more effective, real conversations with patients about those issues.

An Adaptable Model for the Cross-Community Need for Trauma-Informed Care

Your research has looked at a range of women, including transgender women. Have you seen that transgender women and non-transgender women are in need of a similar set of practices and services under trauma-informed primary care, or are there some areas in which transgender women's needs differ, and the response should also address them differently?

The model of trauma-informed primary care that we created with the strategy group isn't really limited to women. There's a large body of data that suggests that lifelong abuse is related to the majority of morbidity, mortality and disability across many diseases in the United States in both men and women -- including heart, lung and liver disease; obesity; diabetes; substance abuse; depression; as well as HIV.

Many transgender women, in particular, have experienced an array of traumas, some of which are unique, I believe, to being a transgender woman -- including widespread discrimination and an unacceptable level of harassment and violence that many experience on a daily basis.

I also believe that this model is appropriate for other populations of people living with HIV. For example, many young, black gay men come from communities that are very violent and who personally may have experienced sexual abuse, neglect and other personal traumas. I don't believe that the model of trauma-informed primary care is substantially different for the various types of individuals affected by trauma, including women, transgender individuals and men. Addressing trauma in all of these populations has the same exciting potential to help transform primary care from treating peoples' symptoms with medications to one that gets to the root of so many problems and is genuinely healing. I believe that this new focus has the potential to significantly improve the primary care experience for both patients and providers, which would be great.

Thanks so much for your work, and for taking time for this interview.

This transcript has been edited for clarity.

Julie "JD" Davids is the managing editor for and

Follow JD on Twitter: @JDAtTheBody.

Copyright © 2014 Remedy Health Media, LLC. All rights reserved.
 < Prev  |  1  |  2  |  3 

Reader Comments:

Comment by: Dilnoz (Tashkent, Uzbekistan) Mon., Jun. 1, 2015 at 6:43 pm UTC
Greetings dear.. my little sister she is 12 years old and she go t infected by AIDS/HIV in the local medical center either by a needle, or either by a dental tool around 2 years ago.Right now she is taking epivir, reterovir, kaletra medicines, and besides that , she is taking one white medicine against tuberculosis every single day we don't know the name of that medicine cause it is given by local tuberculosis center and now my brother is going to USA to New York. I heard that the best medication is USA which prolongs the health of a HIV/AIDS infected person. So as my brother is going now to NEw York What kind of medications should he buy which are not harmful and best useful for my little sister HIV/AIDS infected sister to prolong her life?
Reply to this comment

Comment by: Dianne Nyoni (Sydney, Australia) Sun., Jan. 4, 2015 at 8:39 pm UTC
Thankyou for this detailed work, trauma is indeed prevalent in positive community and I believe a contributing factor. I hope we can all adopt the approach used and demonstrated in this article to approach HIV with a wholistic trauma informed care we can support all who are struggling with a violent history as well as those subjected to trauma daily whilst living with HIV.
Again thankyou as a HIV positive woman.
Reply to this comment

Comment by: Teresa (Floral City, FL) Sat., Jan. 3, 2015 at 9:10 pm UTC
Excellent piece, this is me, but y'all put it in better words then I can.
Reply to this comment

Comment by: Bob (Los Angeles) Thu., Aug. 21, 2014 at 7:47 pm UTC
I think you are missing the forest because of all of the trees. I believe everyone diagnosed with HIV is recovering from trauma. You seem to be working with individuals exposed to multiple levels of trauma, however I would wish you cast a wider net. There is a huge community of people struggling with how to cope with a disease they won't die from but will forever be judged for. These people need help and it's not there. Keep up the great work!
Reply to this comment
Replies to this comment:
Comment by: Edward Machtinger (San Francisco) Sun., Sep. 14, 2014 at 6:44 pm UTC
Great point Bob! I think that the stigma of HIV touches all who are living with it. The stigma of HIV often leads to profound isolation, depression, addiction, and other health problems. One of my greatest hopes is to have clinics that serve people living with HIV have evidence-based services to overcome stigma. One stigma related intervention that we just studied is an intervention (called the Medea Project) that helps women living with HIV develop the confidence and skills to safely and voluntarily publicly disclose their HIV status through dance and theater. Notably, half of those who participated reported leaving or avoiding abusive relationships because they had reduced isolation, made real friends to support them, and overcame many of the debilitating effects of stigma. The people who participated were able to start seeing themselves as much more than just HIV positive and gained a voice to express their beliefs and goals. To your point, helping people cope with HIV in general (in this case by "coming out" and reducing isolation) is key to helping people break the cycle of violence, avoid re-victimization, and overcome stigma. Thanks again for your comment.

Link to tje full article about the disclosure intervention:

Add Your Comment:
(Please note: Your name and comment will be public, and may even show up in
Internet search results. Be careful when providing personal information! Before
adding your comment, please read's Comment Policy.)

Your Name:

Your Location:

(ex: San Francisco, CA)

Your Comment:

Characters remaining:


The content on this page is free of advertiser influence and was produced by our editorial team. See our content and advertising policies.